Package theft has become one of the most common property crimes in the United States. According to data from Security.org, approximately 79 million Americans had at least one package stolen in 2023, and the problem has only grown as online shopping continues to increase. The average value of a stolen package is around $50, but the frustration, the hassle of filing claims, and the violation of having someone take something from your doorstep make it feel much worse than the dollar amount suggests.
The good news: package theft is one of the most preventable property crimes. Porch pirates are overwhelmingly opportunistic — they drive or walk through neighborhoods looking for unattended packages on porches. A few simple measures can make your deliveries significantly harder to steal.
Video Doorbells: The First Line of Defense
A video doorbell is the single most effective tool against package theft. It serves three functions: it deters thieves who see the camera, it records evidence if a theft occurs, and it lets you communicate with delivery drivers in real time.
The deterrent effect is significant. A visible camera at the front door signals that the property is monitored. Many porch pirates will skip a house with a visible doorbell camera and move to the next one without. The camera doesn’t need to be expensive — even a $35 Wyze Video Doorbell or $50 Blink Video Doorbell provides a visible deterrent and records footage of anyone who approaches.
When a delivery arrives, most video doorbells send a push notification to your phone with a snapshot or video clip. You can see the delivery in real time, verify the package was placed safely, and even speak to the delivery driver through two-way audio (“Please put the package behind the planter, thanks”).
If a theft does occur, the doorbell camera captures the thief’s face, clothing, vehicle (if visible), and the time of the theft. This footage is valuable for police reports, insurance claims, and community alerts. Sharing footage on neighborhood platforms (Ring Neighbors, Nextdoor) often leads to identification — porch pirates frequently hit multiple homes in the same area, and someone usually recognizes them.
For package theft prevention specifically, look for a doorbell with: wide field of view (to capture the porch and approach path), person detection (to alert you specifically when a person approaches, not just any motion), package detection (available on Ring and Nest cameras with subscriptions), and adequate night vision (many deliveries happen in the evening).
Package Lock Boxes and Delivery Boxes
A package lock box is a secure container on your porch where delivery drivers can place packages. The driver opens the box, places the package inside, and closes it — the box locks automatically, and only you can open it with a key, code, or app.
Popular package lock box options:
Yale Smart Delivery Box (~$150-$200): A large, weather-resistant box with a smart lock. Delivery drivers open it with a one-time code or by pressing a button. You unlock it with the Yale app or a physical key. Holds packages up to about 20″ × 15″ × 15″.
Bench Sentry (~$200-$350): A porch bench that doubles as a secure package storage compartment. The top lifts open for deliveries and locks closed. It looks like normal porch furniture, which is a nice aesthetic touch.
CleverMade Parcel LockBox (~$100-$150): A collapsible, lockable delivery box. The driver lifts the lid, places the package, and the lid locks when closed. You unlock it with a key. Folds flat when not in use.
DIY options: A large, lockable deck box or storage bench ($50-$100 from hardware stores) with a padlock and a sign instructing drivers to place packages inside works as a budget alternative. It’s not as elegant as a purpose-built delivery box, but it’s functional.
The limitation of lock boxes: they only work if the delivery driver uses them. Include clear delivery instructions in your shipping preferences (“Please place packages in the lock box on the porch”) and consider a visible sign on or near the box with instructions. Most drivers will comply, but some won’t — especially during peak delivery seasons when drivers are rushed.
Delivery Instructions and Alternative Delivery Locations
Most shipping carriers and retailers allow you to specify delivery instructions. Using these effectively can prevent packages from sitting on your porch unattended.
Specific placement instructions: “Leave package behind the large planter on the left side of the porch” or “Place package inside the screen door” or “Deliver to the side door, not the front.” Packages placed out of sight from the street are less likely to be spotted by passing porch pirates.
Amazon delivery options: Amazon offers several alternatives to standard porch delivery. Amazon Key (for compatible smart locks) allows drivers to place packages inside your garage or home. Amazon Locker provides secure pickup locations at convenience stores, grocery stores, and other locations. Amazon Day lets you consolidate all weekly deliveries into a single day, reducing the number of days packages sit on your porch.
Carrier-specific options: UPS My Choice and FedEx Delivery Manager let you redirect packages to a UPS Store, FedEx Office, or other pickup location. You can also schedule delivery for a specific day when you’ll be home, or request that the driver leave the package at a neighbor’s house.
Workplace delivery: If your employer allows it, having packages delivered to your workplace ensures someone is there to receive them. This is one of the simplest and most reliable solutions for people who work outside the home during delivery hours.
Smart Garage Delivery
Several services now allow delivery drivers to place packages inside your garage, eliminating porch exposure entirely.
Amazon Key for Garage: Works with a compatible smart garage door controller (myQ, Chamberlain, LiftMaster). When the driver arrives, they scan the package, the garage door opens, they place the package inside, and the door closes. You receive a notification with a photo confirming delivery. The driver never enters your home — only the garage.
The myQ smart garage controller costs approximately $30-$50 and works with most garage door openers manufactured after 1993. Setup takes about 15 minutes. Amazon Key for Garage is free for Amazon Prime members.
This is one of the most effective package theft solutions available. The package goes directly into a locked, enclosed space that’s not visible from the street. The only requirement is a compatible garage door opener and a Wi-Fi connection in the garage.
Camera-Based Package Monitoring
Beyond doorbell cameras, dedicated porch cameras and package-specific features add additional protection.
Package detection alerts: Ring cameras (with Ring Protect subscription) and Google Nest cameras (with Nest Aware) can specifically detect when a package is placed on your porch and send a “package delivered” alert. Some can also detect when a package is removed and send a “package picked up” alert — useful for distinguishing between a delivery driver placing a package and a thief taking one.
Porch cameras with spotlights: A camera with a built-in spotlight (Ring Spotlight Cam, Arlo Pro 5) can activate the spotlight when someone approaches the porch, drawing attention and deterring theft. The sudden illumination combined with a visible camera is a strong deterrent, especially after dark.
Two-way audio intervention: If you see someone approaching your package on the live camera feed, you can speak through the camera’s two-way audio: “I can see you. That package is being recorded.” This real-time intervention has proven effective in numerous documented cases — most porch pirates flee immediately when they realize they’re being watched and spoken to.
Physical Deterrents and Decoys
Some homeowners have gotten creative with physical deterrents:
Package alarm devices: Products like the PackageSafe alarm attach to your package and sound a loud alarm if the package is moved. The sudden noise startles the thief and draws attention from neighbors. These cost $20-$40 and are reusable.
Glitter bomb / decoy packages: Made famous by YouTuber Mark Rober, decoy packages that spray glitter, emit foul odors, or make loud noises when opened have become a cultural phenomenon. While satisfying to watch, they raise legal concerns in some jurisdictions (booby-trapping) and don’t actually protect your real packages. They’re more entertainment than security strategy.
Cable locks: A cable lock attached to a heavy porch fixture (railing, column, heavy planter) with a loop around the package prevents grab-and-go theft. The thief would need to cut the cable, which takes time and tools. This works best for large, heavy packages that can’t be easily concealed.
Community-Based Solutions
Package theft is a neighborhood problem, and neighborhood solutions are often the most effective.
Neighborhood watch for deliveries: A group text or WhatsApp group where neighbors alert each other about deliveries and suspicious activity. “I just got a delivery — can someone keep an eye out?” or “Suspicious person checking porches on Oak Street” are the kinds of messages that prevent theft.
Shared camera networks: Ring Neighbors and similar platforms let you share camera footage with nearby residents and local police. When a porch pirate hits one house, footage from multiple cameras in the area can track their movements and vehicle, making identification much more likely.
Package holding agreements: Arrange with a trusted neighbor who’s home during the day to receive your packages. Most carriers allow you to specify an alternate delivery address or leave instructions to deliver to a neighbor.
What to Do If a Package Is Stolen
Despite your best efforts, package theft can still happen. Here’s the response protocol:
Check your camera footage immediately. Save and download any relevant clips before they’re overwritten or expire from cloud storage.
File a police report. Even if the police can’t investigate a single package theft, the report creates a record that helps identify patterns and serial offenders. Many police departments have dedicated property crime units that track porch pirate activity.
Contact the retailer. Most major retailers (Amazon, Walmart, Target) will replace stolen packages or issue a refund. Amazon’s policy is generally to replace or refund on the first report without requiring a police report. Repeated claims may require documentation.
Contact the shipping carrier. UPS, FedEx, and USPS all have claims processes for lost or stolen packages. The shipper (retailer) typically files the claim, but you can initiate the process.
Share footage with neighbors and on community platforms. Porch pirates rarely hit just one house — your footage may help identify someone who’s been stealing from multiple homes in the area.
File an insurance claim if the value warrants it. Homeowners and renters insurance may cover package theft, though deductibles often exceed the value of a single stolen package. Document the theft with the police report and camera footage.
Frequently Asked Questions
What time of day are packages most likely to be stolen?
Most package thefts occur between 10 AM and 3 PM on weekdays — the hours when most people are at work and packages are sitting unattended on porches. Holiday season (November-December) sees the highest volume of package theft due to the increase in deliveries.
Do “package stolen” signs deter thieves?
Signs like “Smile, you’re on camera” or “All deliveries are recorded” can deter opportunistic thieves, especially when combined with a visible camera. The sign reinforces the message that the property is monitored. A sign alone (without an actual camera) has limited deterrent value.
Is package theft a felony?
It depends on the value and jurisdiction. In most states, theft under a certain value (typically $500-$1,000) is a misdemeanor. Some states have enacted specific “porch piracy” laws with enhanced penalties. The federal STOP Act of 2021 made mail theft from residential mailboxes a federal offense, but it applies specifically to USPS mail, not packages from private carriers.
Does Amazon replace stolen packages?
Generally, yes. Amazon’s policy is to replace or refund packages reported as stolen. For the first occurrence, they typically process the replacement without requiring additional documentation. Frequent claims may trigger additional verification requirements. Third-party sellers on Amazon may have different policies.
Best Doorbell Camera
Do Security Cameras Deter Crime
Home Security On A Budget
Where To İnstall Security Cameras